Skip to content
Asiatico Law, PLLC
  • Who We Are
    • About Us
    • Meet Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • Our Blog
  • COVID-19 Resources

Related-Party Transactions and Conflicts of Interest: When Good Intentions Create Legal Risk

Home /

Nonprofit Governance /

Related-Party Transactions and Conflicts of Interest: When Good Intentions Create Legal Risk

Related-Party Transactions and Conflicts of Interest: When Good Intentions Create Legal Risk

Summary: 

  • Nonprofit related-party transactions include contracts with board members, executives, relatives, and insider-owned businesses.
  • Conflict disclosures and recusal procedures help boards evaluate connected vendors independently.
  • State nonprofit laws and federal tax rules govern insider transactions; requirements vary by organization and transaction.
  • Documented decisions and accurate Form 990 disclosures support accountability and donor confidence.

Evaluating a vendor gets uncomfortable when the vendor is a fellow board member’s spouse. You want a fair price, reliable service, and a decision everyone can trust. You also want to preserve a relationship with someone who has given years to your mission. A consistent conflict review process helps your board do all of that.

Personal connections need an honest review before money changes hands. That review protects program dollars and gives your board a credible explanation for the decision.

Identify the Connection Before Considering the Deal

A related-party transaction involves your nonprofit and someone connected to its leadership, such as a director, an executive’s relative, or a business an insider owns. Examples include hiring a director’s accounting firm, leasing an officer’s building, and paying a founder for consulting.

A conflict of interest exists when personal interests could interfere with someone’s duty to act for the nonprofit. Financial gain and divided loyalties can both create concerns. Your governance policies should help directors recognize and report those connections.

Account for State and Federal Rules

Nonprofits need to address applicable state statutes and regulations alongside federal tax rules. Requirements vary by state and organizational structure. 

Federal regulations address improper insider benefits. Paying an influential insider excessive compensation may trigger excise taxes and repayment obligations. Private foundations face separate self-dealing restrictions that can prohibit transactions even at fair prices.

The IRS encourages written conflict policies. Adoption is generally optional for federal tax-exempt status, though state requirements may differ. Form 990 asks about policies, annual disclosures, and enforcement.

Make Disclosure and Recusal Routine

Annual disclosures help identify business interests and family relationships. Transaction-specific updates help the board evaluate new connections before approval. Consistent procedures spare directors the discomfort of deciding whether a longtime colleague warrants additional review.

A conflict policy can establish procedures for:

  • Disclosure: Identify the relationship, financial interest, and proposed terms.
  • Recusal: Allow the interested person to provide relevant facts, followed by withdrawal from deliberation and voting.
  • Independent evaluation: Have eligible decision-makers compare prices, services, and alternatives and assess the benefit to the nonprofit.

The applicable law, bylaws, and policy determine the required process. Advance independent approval, appropriate comparison data, and timely documentation can support a federal presumption of reasonableness for qualifying transactions.

Record the Reasons and Protect Donor Trust

Board minutes should document disclosures, recusals, participants, the vote, and the basis for approval, and retain supporting comparisons. A bare “approved unanimously” gives future reviewers little evidence of how the board evaluated an insider arrangement. 

Some transactions also require disclosure on Form 990 and Schedule L. Donors can read those records. Documented mission accountability helps your organization explain why it selected a connected vendor and how that decision served its charitable purpose. 

Pursue Opportunities With a Process You Can Trust

Your board can evaluate personal connections respectfully while protecting the people your nonprofit serves. Asiatico Law PLLC helps nonprofits develop governance procedures suited to their goals and legal obligations. Call 214-570-0700 to discuss a proposed insider transaction or update your board’s disclosure and recusal procedures.


FAQ: Nonprofit Board Conflicts and Related-Party Transactions

Can a nonprofit hire a board member’s business?

In some circumstances, yes. The board needs to evaluate the relationship, proposed terms, applicable law, and its conflict policy. A fair price and board approval may support the arrangement. Private foundations face additional restrictions that can prohibit certain insider transactions even at fair prices.

What should board members disclose about potential conflicts?

Relevant disclosures include ownership interests, paid roles, family connections, and other relationships tied to a proposed decision. Annual disclosures help identify existing connections, while updates before individual transactions allow the board to evaluate new interests.

What does recusal involve?

Recusal involves stepping away from specified parts of a decision. Under a conflict policy, an interested director may provide facts before withdrawing from deliberation and voting. Applicable law, bylaws, and the policy determine the required procedure.

What should a nonprofit document when approving a related-party transaction?

Records should identify the disclosed interest, recusals, participating decision-makers, approved terms, vote, and reasons for approval. Retaining bids, price comparisons, and other supporting material helps explain how the board evaluated the transaction.

Does federal law require every nonprofit to adopt a conflict-of-interest policy?

The IRS encourages written conflict policies, and adopting one is generally optional for federal tax-exempt status. Form 990 asks about policies, annual disclosures, and enforcement. State law may impose additional requirements, and federal restrictions on improper insider benefits apply regardless of whether an organization adopts a policy.

Recent Posts

  • Related-Party Transactions and Conflicts of Interest: When Good Intentions Create Legal Risk

  • A Compliance Framework for Unrelated Business Income

  • How Nonprofits Can Structure Executive Compensation to Meet IRS Standards

  • Gift Acceptance Policies Protect Nonprofit Trust

  • Are You Treating Form 990 With the Care It Deserves?

A Compliance Framework for Unrelated Business Income
Asiatico Law, PLLC
Navigation
  • Who We Are
    • About Us
    • Meet Our Team
      • Brooke Asiatico
  • Practice Areas
    • Nonprofit Formation & Governance
    • Taxes & Exemptions
    • Churches & Religious Organizations
    • Charitable Solicitation Registration
    • Business & Property
    • Employment & Volunteer Solutions
    • Intellectual Property
    • Crisis Management
    • Executive Compensation & Section 4958
    • International
    • Litigation Management & Dispute Resolution
    • Planned Giving, Special Needs Planning, & Estate Planning
  • Our Blog
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Contact Us
  • Plano Office
  • 5801 Headquarters Dr, Suite 700
    Plano, TX 75024
  • 214.570.0700
  • 214.269.4270
  • info@baalegal.com
  • www.baalegal.com
 
  • Tampa Office
  • 3030 N. Rocky Point Drive,
    Suite 650
    Tampa, FL 33607
  • 214.570.0700
  • 214.269.4270
  • info@baalegal.com
  • www.baalegal.com
Social Networks